Friday, January 26, 2007

NY Times Middle School Article

The article pertained to a very important issue. What do we do with the middle school kids? Should we keep them in schools with the younger student and protect them from their future or should we open their eyes to the real world and give them a taste of what life will be like in a mere 3 years. Is it too early to expose them to the rough life of high school where violence and cuss words are common place? Or it it too late to still be protecting the adolescents who eventually need to grow up? Well I am prepared to answer these questions as well as give my own spin on the problem citing personal experiences.

How do you allow an 11-year-old to be walking the same halls as the fully developed 18-year old. So many changes take place in this 7 year window that although it is only 7 years the 18 year-old is vastly different than the 11 year-old who is is walking next to. A student has so much stuff going on in their life during this window that you can't possibly combine children of this vast of an age spread. Well you may be wondering about the alternative which is combining children into a school for Kindergarden through 8th grade. That is a greater spread of ages than the 6-12th grade schools but the children share more in common. Major life changes have begun for the older children but the key is that they have only begun where as in the other school you will have children who have not yet begun their major life changing situations with students who have completed those events. I speak from experience when refering to to the K-8 schools, I grew up in a town where until just recently we had a K-8 school. I attended this school for 9 years until I was promoted to the high school. I never once thought about being in the same school as the little kids as holding me back. I can guarntee as a 6th grader f I were to have entered the high school I would not have been ready for such a change. I feel that it is completely nessasary for the 6th-8th grade group to stay separate from the high school. I understand the point that was made by the principal of Fredrick Douglas Academy that if he was given 7 years to prepare the student for college he would get all the students into college and in fact I believe he would get a high percentage of students into college. I just feel as though the middle school teachers need to work harder to get their students prepared for high school. The academic advantage of combining the 6th-12th grade schools would be gret but the social disadvantage would outway any advantage gained. I feel as though with a little hard work by the middle school teachers we can get the social advantage of the K-8 schools with the academic advantages of preparing the student for the next level.

1 comment:

TexasTheresa said...

good reflection. you're right . . . it comes down to good teaching in those critical years; moving buildings won't make the difference, teachers will.
dr.theresa